Friday, June 3, 2011

Dr. V.T. Impaler Sends a Note to Students, Past and Present.

How do you bug me? Let me count the ways……


  1. By failing to read the syllabus and other documents I provide. I spend a lot of time on these. I write out the assignments and my expectations as clearly as possible in order to help students know exactly what they need to do each week, even if they miss a class. So it annoys the hell out of me when students don’t read them, do poorly because they failed to follow the detailed instructions given in the documents, and then claim that they didn’t know what had to be done because “Dr. Impaler didn’t tell us”. Yes, I did. In class AND IN THE WRITTEN INSTRUCTIONS!
  2. By refusing to learn how to use Moodle. I don’t care if none of your other professors use it. It’s actually University policy that we use it. It also makes life much easier for everyone and keeps at least a ton of paper out of the local landfills every semester, so we’re using it. The End
  3. By expecting special treatment. What’s that you say? Your schedule is so tight that you can only do homework for this class between 8:30 p.m. and 9:10 p.m. on Mondays and this Monday you had to take your friend to the hospital to get stitches in his hand, so you couldn’t get your online quiz done, so you really, really need me to give you a special makeup quiz because you’ve never, ever gotten a grade lower than a B and it’s not fair because you work so very, very hard, and….. Save your breath, dear, since mean old Dr. Impaler is not going to give you a makeup quiz just because you are overscheduled. She won’t do it even if you are trying to keep your scholarship or if this is your last semester before graduation. You’ve had an entire week to get that quiz done, just like every other busy person in the class. Dr. Impaler would have to drop the concept of due dates altogether if she allowed every student who is inconvenienced by them to have a makeup or an extension. Now, granted, even the über-evil Dr. Impaler is willing to work with students who have truly catastrophic situations arise, but she is not at all interested in listening to you dramatize the everyday complications of your life. Here’s one of the Great Truths of existence: everybody’s got problems and whining doesn’t help. And FYI, you might want to rethink your approach to homework.
  4. By not asking questions, then complaining just before the final that you “don’t get” the material. This is why you have weeks and weeks of classes with a professor – so you have someone to ask about the course material. Otherwise, you could just read the book and proceed directly to the final exam, which you would ace of course, since you are, after all, a genius whose natural brilliance and creativity are obviously stifled to the point where the resulting ennui and despair prevent you from participating in class, emailing me, or coming to my office.
  5. By not having your papers printed when they’re due. It’s annoying as hell when students come into class insisting that really and truly their research essay is done, they only needed to print it, but couldn’t because [insert computer-related excuse here]. Well, my young grasshoppers, if the essay isn’t printed, guess what? It’s not done. Here’s another one of those Great Truths: if you wait until the last minute before class to print, every computer and printer in the metropolitan area will spontaneously crash. Print it in advance, or submit it as an attachment via email before class begins since you do have that option. You would know about that if you had just READ THE INSTRUCTIONS.
  6. By using cell phones, BlackBerries, IPads, etc. in class. Dr. Impaler has a policy against that sort of thing for a reason. Well, she is just plain evil, so make that two reasons. Reason #2: Multitasking is a complete myth. You really DO NOT hear what’s going on in class while you’re texting, Tweeting, or updating your Facebook status. It doesn’t matter that you’re not actually talking out loud, you’re still distracting and distracted. You, or more likely someone else, is paying LOTS of money to attend this University, and even though she’s evil, Dr. Impaler hates to look out at the classroom and see thousands of dollars just being pissed away.
  7. By making sotto voce (look it up) comments to your neighbors in class. It’s just plain rude. It’s also annoying as hell. If you have something witty to contribute, say it so that all can hear. It might even make Dr. Impaler revise the opinion of you that she formed after reading your latest research essay.
  8. By moaning, groaning, and theatrical sighing. A disturbing number of students apparently believe that if they groan or sigh when I hand out a test I will say “Oh, gee whiz, I’m so very, very sorry. You all knew this test was coming, I announced it several times and it was listed in the syllabus. But since the idea upsets you so much, we’ll just skip it and I’ll give everyone an A.” It will NEVER, EVER happen that way. You just annoy the hell out of me.
  9. By plagiarizing and otherwise ruining your papers. I get it, I really do. Most of the students here would rather pull their own teeth than write a research paper or an essay. But it’s really not all that difficult for most sentient beings to research a simple topic, organize the information, and then synthesize it into (mostly) their own words in their native language. SO DON’T JUST COPY AND PASTE A BUNCH OF WIKIPEDIA ARTICLES TOGETHER! I warn about this when assigning the papers and essays. I provide websites where you can learn what a research paper or essay is supposed to be, how to use APA format and how to avoid plagiarism, even though you should have done all this before in your composition classes. But I know that when the first essays are turned in at least three will be directly copied from websites. Sometimes the fonts aren’t even changed and they still contain hyperlinks! Or the voice switches from active to passive in the middle of a paragraph! Ninety percent of the remaining essays will be formatted incorrectly, lack citations, or only have half the number of required pages. This is annoying as hell AND insulting; annoying because I know you know better, and insulting because you must think I’m too stupid to notice these things.
  10. By repeatedly asking stupid questions. In spite of what other, lamer professors may have told you, there ARE such things as stupid questions. Here are a few examples: “Is there going to be a quiz?” “When is the final project due?” “I’m going to miss class for two weeks; will we be doing anything important?” The answers to all three may be found in the syllabus, the “Assignments for this week”, or “The final project” documents on Moodle. That last question in particular displays a truly monumental stupidity, especially when it’s directed to the person who will be grading your, for lack of a better word, work.
  11. By displaying absolutely no intellectual curiosity or desire to learn ANYTHING. In fact, let’s make this even stronger: By actively RESISTING your own education. Dr. Impaler is SICK TO DEATH of sitting through oral presentations and reading papers and essays that barely rise to the level of a fourth grade report on “Our Friend the Sun”. Giving these half-assed abominations the failing grades they deserve is no consolation, either. She has attempted to make it abundantly clear in the instructions for the assignments, in the classroom, and in her comments on your graded work what college level research is, but she cannot seem to penetrate the mental barriers thrown up by the more determined ignoramuses. She could not care less if this class isn’t in your major; there is absolutely no excuse for such a blatant refusal to use that gray mass between your ears for something other than ballast. It annoys the hell out of her that “students” such as yourselves have made it as far as her class with this attitude and scares the hell out of her that someone may still give you college degrees and positions of responsibility someday.

15 comments:

  1. "...the mental barriers thrown up by the more determined ignoramuses."

    Classic. Mind if I use that now and then?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dr. Impaler, you are guilty of academic dishonesty-I have been saying this for years and it is obviously public knowledge!!!!! :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. On a slightly more serious "vein", I sent this out last week:
    By now you have received your semester grades and you have, of course, formed an view of how the course was presented by me; good, bad or indifferent.

    Of course, I have also formed a view of the class and how many students dealt with the material presented.

    A few comments and some advice:

    1. The textbook requirement is not an effort on the part of the college to make some extra money. Students that purchase the book late, or not at all, or, fail to read the book and the relevant sections with the examples presented are doing themselves a great disservice.

    2. The homework component of the course was designed to reinforce the material presented in the lectures. Students that did not do the homework on time were not fully prepared for the exams, since each exam covered material on lectures and homework.

    3. As a student, you must be willing to speak up and ask questions-very few questions on homework were asked. There are very few instructors at SCCC who can read minds and know what you don't know or don't understand. If there is a concept that confuses you, rest assured that it most likely confuses at least one other person.

    4. Attendance is paramount. Coming late, leaving early, or missing an entire lecture sets you back. There is nothing harder than trying to catch up in a college mathematics or science course.

    5. Get help sooner rather than later. If an instructor has office hours, make us of the chance to sit down on a one-to-one basis for some extra help. If an instructor is an adjunct, see if you can meet with the instructor at some mutually agreeable time. Make use of the Tutoring Center. It is free and open seven days a week. Private tutors cost between $40 and $100 per hour-the faculty and Tutoring Center charge $0 for some extra help.

    As I noted in the syllabus, statistics is not an easy course. The math itself is not difficult but there are so many different conditions that govern what kind of problem you are dealing with, the only way to learn is by seeing and doing lots of practice problems. This is no different than learning to play the piano. You can take lessons from the greatest teacher of all time, but, if you don't sit down and practice, you'll never learn to play the piano.

    No instructor takes any joy in failing students-we do this job to educate people but it takes two to learn.


    Whether you passed the course, withdrew, or failed, I believe everyone can take something away from this.

    ReplyDelete
  4. AND THIS IS WHAT I RECEIVED FROM ONE STUDENT:


    Mr. X,

    This email is entirely inappropriate.

    First of all, this is my private email, and since getting out of your class and the semester is now over, it is NOT ok for you to email students. Especially an email belittling the class in the things you believe we did not take advantage of.

    You need to take some personal responsibility.

    Your a terrible instructor, you have very, very poor social skills and speaking ability. We asked many questions which you would not answer because you didnt want to "give away the question on the exam". Given the number of people who widthdrew from your class and/or failed, and given the school, state, and national levels of kids who widthdraw or fail, shows that clearly there are more issues going on that classroom than kids simply not reading and/or doing homework.

    I'm 23, work two jobs, train for triathlons, and support myself. I have never failed or widthdrew from a class, but you did not teach, what so ever. There is a difference between someone who knows math and can write it out on a board, and an EDUCATOR who can actually INSTRUCT on the material being covered. I dont care that you went to columbia and had no life, I really, really dont, and no one else did, you may be good at math, but you fail in almost every other peronal aspect that makes up a complete human being.

    I do not want a reponse and if I do there is no telling the waves I will cause in the XCCC community for you. I am very involved, very motivated, and I have also put together letters and petitions that have been sent to ALL the deans in the entire XCCC system and I can only hope no other person ever has to have the displeasure of having you for an instructor.

    With all sincerity,

    X

    ReplyDelete
  5. When I composed that email, I did so 1 week after the end of the semester. Much of the point I cited I gleaned from informal conversations with students at the end of the semester. A number of points I cited I repeated over and over during the semester.

    This was a beginning stats course that is required for a number of different curricula, and there were a number of students taking the course with me after failing the course previously. My reasoning for sending the email was advisory.

    I realize that the email sounds like "sour grapes", on the other hand, I did get emails thanking me for the note as well. It all depends on your point of view.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don't know, I'm with Humungus on this one. I always send out an "end-of-semester, Jerry Springer's final thought" e-mail. Humungus's e-mail contains good advice, and though it may sound a little grapes-y, it's the job of students to be mature enough to accept the advice and not cry over being butthurt by criticism. Especially helpful criticism.

    Whether it was an advisable e-mail to send, it certainly wasn't in appropriate.

    The student's reply, on the other hand, constitutes a threat ("...there is no telling the waves I will cause in the XCCC community for you"). Humungus, if you have a supportive administration and/or counseling center, I'd advise showing them this e-mail. Probably nothing more will come of it, but seriously, there's a huge difference between advice that might have been given too late (your e-mail) and a name-calling, threatening response (your student's e-mail). It couldn't hurt for the Powers That Be to keep this kid on their radar.

    I wish you the best.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dear Dr. H.,

    your email is professional and deals only with issues that will assist them in any other class they take. One certainly can't say the same for the student's reply. It's riddled with personal insults and attacks on your character, and it concludes with a lengthy and pointless threat. (I'll email EVERYBODY! I'll start a petition! You'll be SO SORRY you didn't give me an A!)

    I suppose you can't expect old heads on young shoulders, or entitled, whiny little twerps to behave as if they're not.

    Save your email to the class. Next time you teach the course, edit it a bit (to take out the "now you know what you think about me and the course" line) and show it to the students in the first week; possibly make it part of your introductory lecture. They need to know this stuff in advance. You might want to repeat the exposure every week.

    I like your line about learning statistics & learning the piano btw. I took statistics a long time ago now, rarely showed up, did none of the problem sets (in fact now that I think about it it's not clear in what sense I "took" the course), passed by the skin of my teeth, never could figure out which method to use where, and now many years later I actually have to use some statistics for my own work and I am utterly at sea. Rather wish I'd been paying attention back then; but it wasn't part of my major and, well, it was 2nd year, I was deep in undergrad depression ...

    However, it never occurred to me to blame the instructor! How could I, when I wouldn't have been able to pick him out of a lineup? :)

    MA

    p.s. It was the student's vewy own personal email! Shocking! Then why did he/she give it to the university to use as a contact? It's not as if you're spamming them daily with ViaXXXgra ads.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dr. Impaler,

    I am printing out your glorious smackdown to put up over my desk, to cheer me through my teaching next semester.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh, dear: Dr. Impaler's post got hijacked. I'm with you on the list. Add to the list: "Bringing a writing utensil and paper to class and taking notes is not a strenuous activity."

    Perhaps CM should be mandatory reading for ALL in-coming students. Or... in the case of Lord Humungus, outgoing graduates.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Impaler, Humungus, and Cynic would have been life-saving colleagues when I taught at Crappy Name U. The weak-willed saps I worked with there talked a good game but then folded when they encountered imbecilic students. No one seemed to care that too many of our students were WILLFULLY IGNORANT about just about everything connected to college-level work (from deadlines to plagiarism to sitting their asses in a seat and not annoying everyone). This also included the sequence of classes they needed for their majors!

    Maybe that's a #13: Track your own damn scheduling. If you need a group of 4 classes complete before you can start the advanced sequence, then make sure you can pass all 4 before you start taking the next sequence; you may not be able to take (and pass) all 4 in one term. It's not the instructors fault that you spazzed, ignored all the lessons, and never looked at the book. And if you change your major when you're a senior, prepare to stay an extra year!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I see that the one dissenting comment has disappeared. I hate when that happens, but I understand it. I think Hummungus acted like a bully with the post-semester email. That seems so petty.

    If you really want to help your students, help them during the term. Don't take out your hurt feelings after the semester.

    If I'd been a student of yours, I would not have been nearly so kind as the one who replied to you.

    I would have told you exactly how dense you acted.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Will, you obviously haven't had an entire class rip you apart in evaluations where they blame you because they screwed the pooch. Here's hoping that happens to you soon and often.

    If you follow the website, you might notice the trend is for today's students to never, EVER learn a lesson on their own that they can (and do) take forward to other courses. How else do so many of us have encounters with seniors who decry that no one EVER taught them how to avoid plagiarism? Unless that's the crappiest school on the planet, they're lying. Someone DID teach them, but they didn't bother to learn it.

    I think more instructors should be ENCOURAGED to send out similar missives to the kinder. My favorite prof always handed out a "this is what you should have learned in class" leaflet after the final exam. Most of the students were shocked at what they had learned. Well, the ones who cared, anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Sorry Will--you're wrong on this one. Impaler, Humungus, and Cynic obviously have more experience than you do dealing with the 'flakery that this generation of students seems to be capable of.

    Lord H, I'll second Ruby's advice and add my own: save it, and send a copy to your chair (if s/he is not an asshat).

    I have a "pet peeves" sheet that I post on D2L every semester. The flip side is "How to Succeed in English Class". Dr Impaler's rant sounds remarkably similar to the advice I try to give my students. Do you know who follows it? My returning adult students. The rest of the flakes expect to magically earn a C by doing nothing all semester...

    ReplyDelete
  14. @Will:
    I made it a point to let my students know DURING THE SEMESTER that if they needed some extra help, I could come in early and meet with them one on one. This class met only once a week, for three hours, on a Monday night.

    I also told my students that if they wanted to, I could meet with them on a Sat. morning, before 9 AM, since I had a class at 9 that ran to 12:50PM.

    I had two students that actually took advantage of this, one student came in at 12:50PM at the end of my sat. morning class, unannounced. I sat with her for an hour and went over the questions she had.

    I have always made it my policy to meet with students before class, after class, whenever we could agree to a mutually agreeable time and place.

    For those students that withdrew from my class, want to know their reason: they didn't want to mess up their GPA. Maybe if they devoted more time to the subject???? I can't count how many times students asked to leave early. Why? They had a paper due in another course and needed to spend some time on it. WHAT???????

    I cannot fathom how students seem to feel that the purpose of college is to get a high GPA, leading to a well paying job. They have no clue. I worked as a statistician and served on a hiring committee and whenever we had a candidate, we could care less about their GPA. We wanted to know if they could THINK. We would ask questions like "how many registered cars are there in the U.S.?" The exact answer wasn't what we were looking for, we wanted to see a process, like, how many people are there in the U.S., appx how many have licenses, etc.

    I always tell that story-you need to demonstrate you can solve problems at a practical level, that's what you should be learning in college, how to think analytically.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm with Will and whoever else got bullied.

    I say give all the instruction you want to your students - even how to behave - DURING a semester.

    Contacting them after is just plain creepy. Anyone doing that - especially so passive-aggressively needs to work out issues NOT on former students.

    I agree they're flakier than shit, but then teach them during the semester.

    Berating them afterwards is quite childish.

    ReplyDelete