Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Less Smackdown than Worn Down


My friends and fellow travelers in misery, I am worn out to my soul. This semester is killing me slowly, and I don't know what to do about it.

I'm teaching several sections of Writing for Your Hamster Audience here at LD3C. The course is designed to get students up to speed for Freshman Hamster Composition, the first required course in the Hamster Writing sequence. I'm teaching other courses as well, but I meet only with WfYHA students only on Mondays.

This is a sample--and only a sample--of the students enrolled in these several sections:

Angry Agnes. She was dealt a life lesson over the summer and she's taking it out on me. Surly, uncooperative, unprepared, often absent. Storms out of the room before the end of class, nearly every time. I have no idea why.

Calamity Cal. Has a new crisis every week and doesn't seem to understand that class time is not the time to inform me. Also doesn't seem to understand that his personal crises do not excuse him from the course work. Displays bad attitude when not accommodated--which is every time he opens his mouth to complain about his personal life in class.

Cognitively Disabled Dan, Deb, Dora, Don, and Darlene. Nice students. Very sweet. Attend every class. Do work to the best of their ability. Absolutely incapable of passing the class.

Cognitively Disabled Donna and Dirk. Not nice at all. Mean, loud, angry, frustrated, and absolutely incapable of passing the class.

Conspiracy Theory Conrad. Seemingly normal, otherwise, Conrad thinks that there's a government plot behind everything--absolutely everything--including my desire to get him to read a text as written. At least he's not a jerk.

Dramatic Dharma. Could be related to Calamity Cal. Her temper is a little better.

Disruptive Dave and his sidekick, Sometimes Sam. Dave rarely attends, is never on time, and when he does show up attempts to demand special treatment to get him caught up in the class. This is Sam's behavior some of the time, especially when he comes in late with Dave.

Emailing Emeril. Thinks this is a correspondence course and refuses to hear that he's failing because he's never in class. Tone of his email is becoming increasingly belligerent because he's not getting his way.

Entitled Enrico. Right out of high school, acts as though I owe him a medal when he bothers to show up. Gets loud and puts on a show when I don't drop everything I'm doing, interrupt every lesson, to pay attention to him right now.

Helpful Hal. Still won't stop trying to teach the class that I am teaching.

Leaving Lorraine. Has an appointment to keep every time class meets, before class is over. Becomes irritated when I cannot alter my lesson plans for her.

Mentally Lazy Lucy. Bright woman but won't read directions or listen attentively enough to know what's going on--and she's perfectly capable of doing so. She'd just wants the spoon feeding.

Occasional Ollie, Olivia, Orlando, Olaf, Owen, Ozzie, and the rest of the Occasional Bunch: Students who breeze in and out of my classes to the point of disruption. I don't mean that they come in and out during a class period. These are students who come occasionally and then demand to be caught up right now. These classes are capped at 25 and are full; there are days when a given section will have just seven or eight. Sometimes their attendance is so sporadic that I don't remember their names when they do show up, and that makes them angry.

Quirky Quinn. Wants to be my BFF, still. Follows me. Refuses to do the assignments as assigned, opting to write for a giraffe rather than hamster audience. Interrupts with questions that have nothing to do with class.

Restless Rita, Ron, and Rob. Will not remain in class long enough to hear instructions. Get up to leave the room to talk on the phone endlessly, go to the restroom, get a cup of coffee. Become angry when I won't catch them up right now.

Sleepy Sam. Sleeps through every class and becomes pissed off when I won't catch him up (upon awakening) right now.

Special Edwina. Loudly proclaims that she has suffered through the label of special education. Becomes irritated when she doesn't understand something. Thinks I'm trying to undermine her. Cries often.

Stoned Stan. Guess what he does before class.

Talkative Tom: Still won't shut the tea party up.

Texting Terrance, Tara, and Taylor. Cannot be bothered to put the electronic devices away, then become irritated because I won't re-teach what they missed while texting.

TMI Tammy: Still reveals too much. Cries often.

Underskilled Ernie, Edna, Ursula, Erskine, Umberto, Uta, Erin, Evan, Esteban, Enid, and Ulf. These are the students who do not read or write at the level required for WfYHA. Somehow, they slipped through the placement cracks (and backups) and are taking a class for which they are absolutely not ready. For some, their reading comprehension is too low (at this point) to understand the course; it simply moves to fast for them. For some, their writing skills need much more work before they can pass the course. For several, it's a double whammy; they are not proficient enough in both reading and writing to pass the course. Some are angry and frustrated and take their anger and frustration out on me or act out in other inappropriate ways. Some are resigned and sad. A couple are determined to get what they can out of the course--but still require more time from me than I am capable of giving.


Every day I walk into my classes prepared to teach Writing for Your Hamster Audience. Every day I spend one-quarter to one-third of the class time on something else, from discipline issues to repeating directions and answering questions endlessly--and in many different ways--for those whose comprehension skills are low. I spend most of the class deflecting and containing the anger of one or more students. I spend a good deal of every class connecting dots so close together that the distance between them is barely discernible.

Yes, there are rules about behavioral issues clearly defined in the syllabus. Yes, I enforce the rules--but that takes a huge chunk of my time as well. Yes, some students are tossed out of class.

Yes, there are students ready for this course, and I try with all my might to teach to them. As they are in the minority, however, the majority becomes frustrated and I find myself having to slow down and loop endlessly.

And, yes, others who teach this course experience similar things, but I tend to teach more of these classes than my colleagues do. Yes, yes, yes--the college is aware there's a problem, but that doesn't help me now.

In addition to the class management issues, these students create an enormous amount of extra work for me outside of the classroom. Every time a student is ejected from class for disruption (which happens often enough), I am required to write a report and do some follow-up with those who take care of such things. Even when students aren't ejected, I document everything because who knows when something that happened in class will come back to bite me?

Then there's the grading. I don't even want to talk about the grading. I am thankful that no one has become violent. I have been called some really awful names.

I am an encouraging, effective, approachable teacher, which is why the college wants me to teach these courses and why I'm pretty good at what I do. I'm no doormat in the classroom, either--another reason I'm a good choice for these courses.

I'm also, however, a teacher who feels worn down to the nub. I feel like I'm spitting into the ocean, howling into the void. It's not even midterm--and midterm brings mandatory one-on-one conferences with each student.

Every day I come home exhausted, and more and more that exhaustion feels akin to heartbreak.

16 comments:

  1. Oh, Greta. I feel your pain. I can't imagine all the documentation you have to do. That sucks.

    But if it is any consolation, even at my fancy, expensive, ranked, private school I have at least one of each variety of student that you have described. My personal favorite this term is Texting Taylor, I've not seen his ear canals ... ever.... He messes with his iPhone every lecture. I'm sure if I took his iDevice away he'd simply melt.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You're articulating many of the reasons I can't bring myself to teach more than one developmental English class at a time, and even then not more than maybe one every couple of years. For every one we get who will actually benefit and is ready to do so, there are three who might if they didn't have discipline issues, two who might if they didn't have soap opera lives, and two who are never, ever going to get it but are being warehoused since we in CC Universe must take all comers.

    And sadly, since now the mantra is "Don't hold them back from succeeding," we at Large Urban Community College are pushing acceleration on all our top-scoring developmental students. Thus they end up in drill 'n kill remediation in hopes of getting their test scores up enough to put them in freshman comp even though it's practice they need, not multiple choice grammar and punctuation quizzes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Greta, I cannot imagine what it's like for you. Thank you for fighting the good fight for those of us in the upper numbers, so that the students who end up in my classes have passed through your (and others like you) caring and compassionate hands.

    Sometimes, you cannot save students from themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm so sorry things are going so badly. I had a class like yours last year -- incomprehensibly out of control, even after polite but firm warnings about my willingness to kick people out and even lay misconduct charges. I suggest that you use institutional law to maximal advantage. Move with alacrity on each occasion.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel a bit like Helpful Hal. I'm taking a few undergrad classes right now for a thing I need to do and I'm twice the age of the others in the room and have 20 to 50 times the academic experience of any of them. I feel like the shark in the pond and have to almost physically restrain myself from constantly raising my hand to respond, for the "teacher", to various remarks made by my classmates. After more than 10 years teaching at the college level, this is a new role for me. My teaching experience gives me enough insight and empathy, however, to be aware of what is going on - so I do find the restraint. I am one of the more active students in class, but I'm making a valiant effort to not be too "helpful"!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wait, you get a developmental English class? Lucky! At my uni they can't read or write but I am expected to teach them composition at the same time I am teaching them the course.

    I feel your pain. My dean also made me apologize to a student whom I was holding to academic standards because I was seen as "mean". I was told I need to appear to be more understanding and empathetic so that the student could make it through the course. That's right, not concerned if the student was doing the work or learning anything, that they could make it through the course and graduate. I hope the dean gets this student as a nurse some day.

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Greta: I just wanted to add my thanks to Allison's. I teach all gen ed, writing-intensive classes, but they're at the other end of the pipeline, as students are beginning to get into, and write in, their majors, and, though my students are far from uniformly delightful, the great majority are, at least, minimally competent, thanks to the teaching and winnowing done by others, many of them at our local cc. I can honestly say that I don't think I could do what you do -- and somebody absolutely needs to do it, and those who are willing and able should be paid handsomely and supported unquestioningly (I know; fat chance).

    Is there any chance of a sabbatical on the horizon, or at least a break from teaching these particular classes? Any chance of your getting a grant to train *others* to teach these classes (which could be a win in several ways)? It sounds like you really need a respite of some sort, soon. Even combat soldiers get to rotate off the front line for a while now and then. It won't benefit your institution any more than it benefits you if they work you to the point of exhaustion.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ohhh Greta. How terrible. I get CC students as transfers, and they are almost always better than the 4-year students. So thank you. But I wish I could get you a sabbatical.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wow, Greta! I know how you feel, even if I can't help you 'fix' the problem this year. It sounds like no one can really 'fix' this problem except those who allowed these students to think they could function in college. This should be forwarded to Admissions Staff so they see what we deal with when they let anyone in (that said, perhaps you teach at a community college where they do, indeed, let anyone in). My SLAC needs money, so it functions like a CC.

    I wonder how much of our misery generates from the LEVELS we teach, as well as the discipline. I suspect that those of us doing general eds (particularly developmental/remedial sequences) suffer more soul-sucking misery than others. Some of my colleagues who teach only upper-division or discipline-specific courses seem skeptical of my experiences with these students. They are less miserable than I am.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Oh, Wow, Greta, I'm so sorry! I'm glad you shared this... from the specific students to the overall course. Here's to hoping it gets better...

    ReplyDelete
  11. I wonder if forwarding this to your dean will get you a much-needed sabbatical.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you, dear Greta
    For your endless toil and grief.
    Hope it's better soon!

    Sorry...thought maybe a bad haiku would cheer you! I agree...I think all dev ed folks should get rotated out every couple of terms. And combat pay.

    Another suggestion, if you have tenure: go ape shit crazy on their collective asses someday. Slam a book to the floor and pitch an epic hissy fit, replete with liberal sprinkles of the f bomb: "how do you f###ing f###s expect me to effing teach you shit when you're so effing ridiculous? Texting Tara, if you dont stow that iPhone, I'm gonna shove it up your iAss. Restless Rita, if you so much as twitch, I'm gonna duct tape your ass to your chair. TMI Tammy, write this on your arm: No. One. Cares. And if you cry again, I'll give you something for reals to cry about."

    Then smooth your hair, pick up the book, and sweetly continue as yourself as if nothing had happened.

    Or hone your impersonation of the little kid in the film The Shining: crook your index finger at them and croak "Redrum. Redrum."

    Take care of yourself. I hope it turns for the better.

    ReplyDelete
  13. When I was an adjunct, I was assigned all developmental writing classes because I worked well with that population.

    I soon felt the way you do. I went to the director of the writing program and told her I simply could not do it and needed to teach a standard comp class and maybe a lit class. She scoffed at me and questioned my ability to do this (since I had not since grad school). I really needed the money, but felt like I was going crazy. To be fair, I did have my husband's salary supporting us, so I suppose I was not desperate, but we had been relying on that extra income for sure.

    I told her I could not teach any more sections of the dev courses, I think I said, "I feel like I hate these people!" I know I said something like that. She told me she did not know if she had any extra sections of regular comp to offer me next time, clearly a threat. I said so be it.

    I walked out of there, and when I got my schedule, I got my full course load of regular comp classes. She was just bluffing I guess.

    Sadly, where I now teach (regular comp ) full time, they do not allow the developmental studies comp teachers to move over into regular comp. They think of it as a whole separate discipline and try to feed them this bull shit about they have specialized skills.

    I think we should all be teaching both, because then we'd understand more each others' plights (the college level comp teachers are always pissed at the dev studies profs for sending them folks who can't write....the dev studies profs think they just don't understand---we don't, even I don't as much anymore because it has been quite a few years here full time teaching only "college level" classes.)

    I guess I think though, that if you really make your needs known, if you stand your ground, they might relent and let you take a break from it. It is worth a shot.

    ReplyDelete
  14. During my early career, I was teaching HS while earning my teaching credentials. It wasn't long before I joined the chorus asking the rhetorical question -- How do the students come to us so un/underprepared?

    I actually got the chance to ask a middle school teacher who was a classmate in the teacher prep program. I was disheartened, though not totally surprised, to hear that teacher complain that THEY spend most of their time trying to catch middle schoolers up to what should have been mastered in elementary school.

    Yes, I later was able to ask an elementary level teacher who, yup, reported that they spend the majority of their time trying to cover the pre-school competencies which were ignored.

    And so, EnglishDoc et al, I feel your pain as I cannot get my Hamster Health students to read and apply the feedback they have gotten on assignments they have submitted to me.

    In fact, a la stupidest questions, this morning I had an Email from a student in a panic because she doesn't understand "what is wanted" in a basic compare and contrast paper.

    And so it goes ...

    ReplyDelete
  15. Frog and Toad, that's the one thing that often keeps me going--knowing that the students who do succeed in my courses really become excellent students, often better than their counterparts who didn't take dev ed classes.

    I was hired to teach both developmental and standard classes. Now that I have tenure, I plan to take a break from the dev ed. In the standard classes, I still get students who are incredibly underprepared, but many of the behavioral issues are missing. Also, you rarely get students in the standard classes who have cognitive and other disabilities that literally prevent them from being capable of working at that level.

    Since I was hired here a few years ago, we've seen an incredible increase in the kinds of students I describe in this post. My first few terms teaching, I encountered a few of these students here and there; now, I have multiples in every single class, students with a range of things that simply cannot be addressed in the courses I teach--and issues that create all kinds of problems in the classroom.

    I haven't even mentioned the ex-cons who make a point of letting you know of the repayment of their debt to society. Some of these are violent and long-term offenders. If they didn't tell me, I wouldn't even know. These ladies and gents are quick to complain to higher-ups about any perceived slight.

    Nor have I yet mentioned the amount of Jesus that is proclaimed every semester--and the offense students take when I politely point out that not everyone within earshot (i.e., their audience) believes as they do and that religious proclamations are not necessarily appropriate in professional settings. These ladies and gents are also quick to complain to higher-ups about any perceived slight.

    Nor have I yet mentioned the heartbreak of watching students who don't complain suffer through real-life crises, like the violence in their lives, the homelessness, the hunger (literally),the disease, the fractured lives they try to manage without complaint. These ladies and gents never complain to higher-ups. Sometimes they write--eloquently, quietly, matter-of-factly--about their issues in their essays. Sometimes they don't.

    Our society is seriously broken. I knew the U.S. was in trouble long ago, but I didn't know how bad things were until I started teaching dev ed classes at my last gig.

    And lest readers here miss this point, let me reiterate: The people I describe are no longer the minority in this country, in any sense of that word. They're just not as visible to the majority of people in higher education. Often they don't make it past dev ed...but colleges still take their money (or government money on their behalf) and colleges still tell them that they can succeed if they try hard enough and teachers still attempt to teach them until those teachers burn out.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Oh, Greta, I feel your pain. I feel it in the marrow of my bones.

    And EnglishDoc, I'm fighting the kill-and-drill mentality on my campus: our associate dean wanted to run our comp courses (plus developmental comp) in 5 week sessions as hybrid (1 class f2f, 1 class online)over the summer session (which around here is a test run for regular semester sessions--I could see where she was going, future-wise: running 3 5 week hybrid comp courses during the regular semester). I said absolutely not, as it's not pedagogically sound. Luckily she listened to me, so now the courses are 7 week summer sessions. But Jesus H Christ, I can see I'm fighting a losing battle.

    The more shit like this that comes down the pipe, the more it looks like I'll be leaving education like a rat off a sinking ship, because I certainly don't see the point in going down with it--not with the current anti-teacher crap happening all over this country.

    So, Greta, I hear you.

    Chrome out.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.