You insist you are an "educated individual," but I checked your transcript and your "education," such as it is, entirely consists of transfer credits from a community college subsequently closed because the students were, and I'm quoting the accrediting board here, "too dim to find their way out of the campus parking lot." Like, seriously stupid. How stupid? “They put a blanket over the SGA president's head and he twisted himself into a ball and suffocated” kind of stupid. “The math teacher used a laser pointer and everyone in the class threw themselves at the screen and died of head trauma” kind of stupid. Seriously, seriously stupid. It took you several years but now you have landed here, in the always dubious "education" major.
You claim you don't know why your papers are failing. That you don't know what tools I'm using for evaluation. The tool I use for evaluation is called a BRAIN, Dumbass Dinah. And my BRAIN has been sending you many coded messages about the criteria for evaluation. Those messages are coded in letters and words that form themselves into a language called ENGLISH, which, believe it or not, is the language in which the syllabus is written, as well as the language in which I compose the comments on your sorry papers. It’s not fucking Farsi. Or Cuneiform. You don’t need the Rosetta Stone to decipher it. It’s all there in your native tongue.
And though there are some people that I would allow to tell me how to do my job, you, Dumbass Dinah, are not one of them. You insist that I should be helping students to succeed, rather than “seeing how difficult I can make things for them.” Unfortunately for you, making things difficult for students is pretty much my raison d’etre. If you want things to be easy for you, become an ed major. Oh, wait…
I understand as well that you’d like information regarding my history as a professor so that you can bolster your mistaken belief that I am somehow unfair. But I am not telling you anything about my “past record of student success,” especially when you don’t have a clue what “student success” is. In your head it probably equates with the number of students that receive high grades, because in your addled brain you think a teacher that hands out A's like candy is a sure sign that the teacher is “successful”. The average grade in my class is also none of your fucking business, and I don’t even know. I can say that about half of the students that begin my classes end up finishing them. And that those students that finish tend to do fairly well. They do well because by then I’ve weeded out all the Dumbass Dinahs. This, Dumbass Dinah, is also my job. I am that great, rusty, mean-looking hooked thing hanging on the garage wall, occasionally descending upon the garden to relentlessly comb through the crabgrass and ragweed, pulling them out by the roots, so that only the flowers survive.
To the rest of my internet summer students:
Perhaps you think that because this is an internet class, and you don’t know who the fuck I am, or my level of experience, or my age, or my accomplishments, or the fact that I’ve been teaching since waaaay before every single one of you was born, that you can bully me as you probably bullied your hapless high school teachers, or the unfortunate adjuncts that you managed to terrify in your former lives as community college students. Perhaps because we have not breathed the same air, or stood in the same space, you have not recognized me for the creature that I am. That creature is a bulletproof full professor with tenure, who isn’t scared of you, or your cohort, or frankly much of anything else except old age, the death of loved ones, and another Bush presidency.
Fuck you.
You're lucky you get to do some "weeding". Where I used to teach, passing Dumbass Dinah would have been my priority and I would have caught holy hell from my masters if she didn't.
ReplyDeletePart of the reason, I assume, why you are no longer an academic.
DeleteYup.
DeleteBut it wasn't because the students couldn't see me if they needed assistance. I put my office address, telephone number, and e-mail address on the course handout that I gave to all the students at the beginning of the course. I also encouraged them to make an appointment to see me if necessary.
Did they come? Of course not. But that was more than enough reason for my masters to make my life miserable.
Sad, isn't it, that places like Dina's former college do exist. They make homelessness seem almost worth it.
ReplyDeleteYears ago, I used to chat with someone who taught in a local for-profit business college. We swapped stories about our teaching experiences and he often reminded me of how lucky I was at my former employer. According to him, his students were the sort that the institution I was at would never accept. Ouch!
Delete“'The math teacher used a laser pointer and everyone in the class threw themselves at the screen and died of head trauma' kind of stupid."
ReplyDeleteAnd, as usual after a Stella Smackdown (yes, this should be capitalized), I'm cleaning gin and tonic from my monitor.
The blanket one did it for me! I just valiantly tried not to spit Greek yogurt on my iPod.
DeleteStella: you are the goddess of smackdowns!
Agreed! EPIC takedown, Stella!
DeleteYou know what is really bad? I had to think for a minute to figure out if the laser pointer comment was real. That tells you the kind of students I have encountered recently!
DeleteIndeed,
DeleteInstructor points lazer pointer at board, students complain on evaluation.
"Those messages are coded in letters and words that form themselves into a language called ENGLISH,. . . " A nice Pinot Grigio out the nose. The tags also got me.
ReplyDeleteIt's especially sweet that Dinah plans to be a teacher. If she ever gets as accomplished and experienced as Stella, how will Dinah like having an incompetent student question her competence?
Worse: will she be able to recognize when her own students are more competent than she is?
DeleteThis post is a Thing of Beauty, and therefore a Joy Forever. Or at least POW.
ReplyDeleteI stood up and cheered. I'm almost inspired to tell the tale of woe about Arrogant Annie/Egotistical Ellen/Narcissistic Nellie. Perhaps when I can settle on a name for her...
ReplyDeletePlease do!
DeleteBrilliant! Online students do, indeed, seem more inclined to question our credentials.
ReplyDeleteFor the moment, I, too, am free to weed the ones who can't or won't do the work out, and a fair proportion do drop by the wayside, especially in intensive summer classes. But there is muttering about "retention," and I don't have (and am not eligible for) tenure. The day it becomes my job (rather than theirs) to ensure the "success" of the Dinahs of this world, I may just quit.
In the meantime, my list of fears is much like yours. As long as my school keeps backing me up, I don't mind standing up to students. I also don't mind helping them, but a little humility in the approach goes a long, long way.